New Video: All Quiet

Now that all the centenery ‘celebrations’ of the First World War have been and gone, it’s time to look at how (and why) the rituals used to commemorate this and subsequent wars came about. This is a video I’ve just finished which is another look at The Two Minutes Silence – I’ve made videos, audio recordings and still photographs of various silences over the past few years and will probably do so again, but here, for now, is the Daddy of them all…

Filmed at 11am on Sunday 11th November 2018 – Exactly 100 years after the Armistice which ended the First World War. This was filmed on Horse Guards Parade where the artillery gun is fired to signal the beginning and end of the Two Minutes Silence. – But there can never be absolute silence or absolute stillness. The Two Minute Silence begins while the echo of the shot is still fading. Big Ben chimes Eleven o’ Clock (The bells had not been heard for months while the bell tower was being renovated). People pause, but there are still sounds – Car alarms set off by the gun, cop car sirens, wind noise. There is still movement – Leaves being blown, birds flying, flags fluttering, feet shuffling, the London Eye turning. And when the Two Minutes are up, the gun is fired again, the Last Post is played on bugles and then the crowds have to decide what they will say. There is laughter – one of the soldiers can’t get back on his horse… At the end of the First World War, the British government planned a grand parade to celebrate the allied victory. But to the bereaved families and maimed soldiers, it may have seemed a hollow victory. The public mood was more for reflection and remembrance than for more of the jingoism that had marched them off to “The Great War”. But remembrance was wrapped up in a shroud of memorialisation and hidden under a draped flag of Empire. and The memorials, notably the Cenotaph in Whitehall and Tomb of the Unknown Warrior in Westminster Abbey, and acts of remembrance, particularly the Two Minutes Silence, said more about what had been lost than anything that had been won. It was a silence that told them to shut up and say nothing.

The Daily Herald carried a front page editorial on 11 November 1919: “You will be asked to be silent for two minutes to-day, to be silent and pause your labours to remember this day and this hour last year… “What will you remember and what will you forget? … The crime that called these men to battle… The war that was to end war and in reality did not?…

2 thoughts on “New Video: All Quiet

  1. Very good piece that Dave. You’ve many have inspired me into making a film about people working doing nothing. By the way what war related endeavour are we commemorating this year as I’m sure there’ll be one. Bakewell has a very strong British legion and they’re big on war commemorations. Last year we had flags everywhere and those dreadful giant plastic poppies on every lamp post welcoming you into bakewell. Anyway hope all is well I’m in Blackpool working for a day or so and three is something about it that I really do find specials still. P


  2. Well, the sharp-eyed amongst you may have noticed many First World War memorials have 1919 rather than 1918 as the end date – so people can ‘celebrate’ Britain and allies fighting against the Bolsheviks in their erstwhile ally, Russia – Or get out the bunting to remember the Paris Peace Conference that was the formal end of the First World War and made decisions that would lead to there being a Second World War, not to mention carving up the middle east and setting things up for the Third. – So don’t be so quick to put that bunting away!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s